The steel sector's 22% surge fooled most investors into thinking the tariff story was simple. But sophisticated traders are now positioning for what comes next after this week's 6.5% Cleveland-Cliffs crash revealed the sector's Achilles heel—and why the next 30 days could determine whether this rally was a gift or a trap.
A trusted partner has just passed onto our desk the presentation below. This is a must watch.
The media elites completely missed what Trump is doing with his tariff strategy...
He's not just creating chaos—he's rebuilding America's industrial backbone.
At the heart of this resurgence is steel production. And you can't make premium steel without high-quality metallurgical coal.
While Germany struggles with low-quality coal, America is blessed with huge reserves of premium, high-grade coal—exactly what's needed to produce the top-quality steel that gives our country a competitive edge.
One powerhouse, [REDACTED], operates 17 facilities across seven states, producing an astonishing 115 million tons of coal in 2024 alone.
Here's the opportunity most investors are missing:
When Trump's policies fully kick in, America's premium metallurgical coal producers will be at the forefront of the "Make American Steel Great Again" movement.
The U.S. steel industry experienced its most dramatic policy shift in decades when President Trump doubled steel and aluminum tariffs to 50% during a May 30 rally at U.S. Steel's Pennsylvania plant, triggering explosive gains followed by volatile reversals that reveal the sector's true risk profile. While the tariffs initially sent Cleveland-Cliffs soaring 22% and Nucor up 12%, recent developments have exposed the fragility of the rally—with steel stocks crashing 6.5% just two weeks ago on news of potential Mexico tariff negotiations. The sector now sits at a critical inflection point as Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick leads talks that could allow duty-free Mexican steel imports up to historical volume thresholds, potentially undermining the protective barrier that sparked the initial euphoria.
Cleveland-Cliffs jumped 22%, Steel Dynamics surged 13%, and Nucor rose 12% in a single day following Trump's tariff announcement.
Steel stocks delivered some of their biggest single-day gains in recent memory as investors immediately grasped the implications of the tariff doubling. Cleveland-Cliffs exploded 22% higher, while Steel Dynamics surged more than 13% and Nucor jumped over 12%, with the VanEck Steel ETF (SLX) gaining more than 3%. The violent market reaction reflected the understanding that a 50% tariff effectively eliminates foreign competition, handing domestic producers unprecedented pricing power.
As Trump stated at the Pennsylvania rally, "At 25%, they can sort of get over that fence. At 50%, they can no longer get over the fence." This single statement captured why the market reacted so explosively to the tariff doubling announcement.
Cleveland-Cliffs crashed 6.5% and Nucor fell 4% when Mexico tariff deal rumors surfaced, proving how fragile the rally really is.
The steel sector's euphoria came crashing down just two weeks ago when reports emerged that the U.S. and Mexico are nearing a deal to ease Trump's 50% steel tariffs through a quota system. Cleveland-Cliffs plummeted 6.5%, Nucor dropped 4%, and U.S. Steel declined 0.2% as investors realized the protective tariff wall might not be permanent.
The proposed agreement would establish a cap on Mexican steel imports based on historical trade volumes, with the 50% tariffs only applying above that threshold. According to Bloomberg sources, the new cap would actually be higher than what was permitted during Trump's first administration, potentially flooding the market with cheaper Mexican steel and eroding the pricing power that drove the sector's initial rally.
This is where your normal page content would be. The countdown modal will appear automatically.
Jeff Brown recently traveled to a ghost town in the middle of an American desert…
To investigate what could be the biggest technology story of this decade.
In short, he believes what he's holding in his hand is the key to the $100 trillion AI boom…
And only one company here in the U.S. can mine this obscure metal.
Despite tariffs meant to protect jobs, Cleveland-Cliffs laid off 1,200+ workers as higher steel costs dampened demand.
Despite the protective tariffs designed to boost American steel jobs, Cleveland-Cliffs has laid off more than 1,200 workers as higher import barriers paradoxically reduced demand in key sectors. The employment cuts expose a fundamental flaw in the tariff strategy—while domestic producers can charge higher prices, those increased costs are being passed through to industries like automotive and construction, dampening overall steel consumption.
Meanwhile, Nucor's latest guidance shows the harsh reality behind the stock rallies, with the company expecting Q1 2025 steel mill earnings to perform similarly to Q4 2024, when earnings fell 71% year over year. The disconnect between soaring stock prices and deteriorating fundamentals suggests the market may have gotten ahead of itself.
Steel prices jumped from $725 to $875 per metric ton—a 21% increase that justified the explosive stock rally.
The initial tariff increase did deliver the pricing power steel companies desperately needed, with benchmark steel prices surging from $725 per metric ton before Trump took office to $875 per metric ton—a 21% increase that justified the sector's explosive rally. The pricing gap between U.S. and foreign steel became even more pronounced, with American steel costing $984 per metric ton compared to just $690 in Europe and $392 in China as of March 2025.
However, this pricing advantage is now under threat as potential Mexico deal negotiations reveal how quickly the protective tariff structure could unravel. The United States produces about three times more steel than it imports, which should position domestic companies to benefit—but only if the trade protection remains intact.
Cleveland-Cliffs' higher debt levels make it the most sensitive to steel price movements—both up and down.
Cleveland-Cliffs' dramatic swings—from a 22% surge on the tariff announcement to a 6.5% crash on Mexico deal rumors—perfectly illustrate why sophisticated investors are both attracted to and wary of this high-leverage play. According to analysts at Jefferies, Cleveland-Cliffs is more highly leveraged than other steel companies, meaning its stock price is disproportionately affected by both positive and negative steel price movements.
The company's recent struggles include laying off over 1,200 workers and posting a net loss of $230 million in Q3, compared to a $275 million profit in the same quarter of 2023. However, this leverage dynamic also means Cleveland-Cliffs could deliver outsized returns if the tariff protection holds—making it the ultimate barometer for the sector's future direction.
The U.S. Steel-Nippon partnership represents the largest foreign industrial investment in U.S. steel infrastructure in decades.
The U.S. Steel-Nippon partnership adds a crucial strategic element to the tariff story, creating what Trump described as a "blockbuster agreement" that ensures the iconic American company "stays an American company." The deal includes U.S. government "golden share" veto power over board appointments, an American CEO, and a majority American board.
With promises of no layoffs and $5,000 bonuses for steelworkers, plus billions in facility upgrades across Pennsylvania, Indiana, Alabama, Arkansas, and Minnesota, the partnership represents the largest foreign industrial investment in U.S. steel infrastructure in decades.
Europe is "prepared to impose countermeasures," while Australia called the tariffs "unjustified."
The aggressive tariff increase has already prompted stern warnings from international partners, with the European Commission stating that Europe is "prepared to impose countermeasures" and calling the decision one that "adds further uncertainty to the global economy." Australia's Trade Minister condemned the move as "unjustified and not the act of a friend."
However, these retaliation threats may be limited by the ongoing 90-day tariff pause that began in April, as the administration seeks broader trade deals that could potentially modify the steel tariff structure.
The Mexico negotiations could determine the sector's fate within the next 30 days—making timing critical.
The steel sector now presents a high-stakes binary outcome that could generate explosive returns or devastating losses depending on how the Mexico negotiations unfold over the next 30 days. The most astute investors recognize this isn't just about steel tariffs anymore—it's about identifying companies with the operational flexibility and financial strength to survive potential policy reversals while maintaining upside exposure if protection remains.
The recent 6.5% Cleveland-Cliffs crash demonstrates how quickly sentiment can shift, creating both danger and opportunity for those who understand the leverage dynamics at play. While the sector offers compelling upside if Trump maintains his protectionist stance, the Mexico deal negotiations prove that trade policy can change overnight, making position sizing and risk management more critical than stock selection.
Those who can navigate this volatility—with the right combination of sector exposure and downside protection—may find themselves riding one of the most explosive policy-driven rallies in years, or avoiding one of the most devastating reversals.
|
✓
Trusted Partner Presentation
Nvidia, AMD, Intel, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing, Google, Microsoft, Apple, Tesla, Oracle, Palantir, IBM… They all need this little-known company's product. And this company has a virtual monopoly in the U.S. That means this company that's located in an American ghost town — with only 30 people — could be the key to the $100 trillion AI boom.
|
A revolutionary new robot is beginning to emerge from the shadows. Elon Musk says it will "change civilization as we know it" while Bill Gates calls it "as revolutionary as the PC." But here's what they're not telling you about the stock positioned to dominate this trillion opportunity.
While everyone obsesses over AI chips, a massive energy crisis is brewing behind the scenes. Data centers will consume 160% more electricity by 2030, and there's only one power source that can handle this 24/7 demand. Three overlooked nuclear companies are positioned to become the backbone of the AI revolution.
This strange map reveals the locations the US government has begun selling off vast tracks of public lands to energy firms seeking to tap a new energy discovery in Utah. It's not nuclear, solar, wind, oil, gas, or coal... but it could provide virtually limitless energy to our country, forever.
MyInvestorNewsAndReports.com, a brand under Market Insiders Media dba, operates under the parent company Sandpiper Marketing Group, LLC. Please be advised that MyInvestorNewsAndReports.com is not registered as an investment adviser or broker-dealer with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission or any state regulatory agency. We rely on the "publisher's exclusion" from the definition of investment adviser as set forth in Section 202(a)(11) of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended, as well as corresponding state securities laws. Consequently, MyInvestorNewsAndReports.com does not offer or provide personalized investment advice.
The information we provide is based on our opinions, statistical and financial data, and independent research of public information. Our materials are intended for informational purposes only, and no mention of a specific security in any of our content constitutes a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold that or any other security. Any information deemed to be investment opinion is impersonal and not tailored to the investment needs of any individual.
Please be aware that MyInvestorNewsAndReports.com does not promise, guarantee, or imply that any information provided through our websites, newsletters, reports, or printed material will result in profit or loss. We strongly encourage you to seek personal advice from your professional investment, tax, or legal advisors and to conduct your own due diligence and independent investigations before acting on any information we publish or making any investment decision. Only you and your professional advisors can determine the level of risk appropriate for you. Penny stocks, in particular, are inherently speculative investments, and you should be prepared to lose your entire investment.
Employees, owners, and/or writers of MyInvestorNewsAndReports.com may own positions in the equities, options, and/or securities mentioned in our content. However, no associated employees will intentionally engage in any transaction that directly or indirectly competes with the interests of our subscribers. MyInvestorNewsAndReports.com may be compensated for publishing information about companies referred to in our reports, newsletters, and websites, and we provide full disclosure of such compensation.
Furthermore, please note that any content marked as "Sponsor" may be paid for and is not endorsed or warranted by our staff or company. The content in our emails is for educational or entertainment use and is not a substitute for professional advice or an offer to buy or sell any securities. Neither the publisher nor the editors are registered investment advisors (RIA’s) and do not provide personalized counseling. Be sure to conduct your own careful research and consult with your advisors before taking any action based on our content. By opening our emails or clicking any links contained therein, you are reconfirming your opt-in status, which is part of your free subscription.
